Election results finalised following draw

UPDATE: Results from the judicial recount for the Galatea-Murupara Ward of the Whakatāne District Council were released today following a tie of votes at the triennial election.

The final vote count released on 18 October 2019 showed that candidates Hinerangi Goodman and Alison Silcock had drawn with 262 votes each. Where this occurs the Local Electoral Regulations 2001 state that the successful candidate will be decided by lot, and this was undertaken on 18 October 2019 by Electoral Officer Dale Ofsoske.

The successful candidate drawn by lot was Hinerangi Goodman, however a judicial recount was called for. This took place today under the supervision of a District Court Judge with the outcome determining Alison Silcock the successful candidate by a one vote margin. Electoral Officer Dale Ofsoske says the recount process was carried out under strict conditions.


Results for the 2019-22 triennium Local Elections for Mayor, Council and Community Board have been finalised following a tie in the Murupara-Galatea Ward of the Whakatane District Council elections.

The final vote count showed that candidates Hinerangi Goodman and Alison Silcock had drawn with 262 votes each.

Clause 58(5) of The Local Electoral Regulations 2001 states that the successful candidate will be decided by lot, and this was undertaken late Friday afternoon by Electoral Officer Dale Ofsoske from Election Services.

The successful candidate drawn was Hinerangi Goodman, who is now elected to Council. Electoral Officer Dale Ofsoske says this situation was unprecedented for the Whakatane District Council in determining its councillors.

“This has been a challenging situation for the candidates, and highlights the adage that ‘every vote counts’,” says Dale. “There is a clear and definite process to follow under the guidance of Local Electoral Act 2001 when there is a tie, and this has been the only way to determine the successful candidate.”

Judy Turner was elected as mayor of Whakatane District Council, along with councillors John Pullar, Victor Luca, Lesley Immink, Julie Jukes, Nandor Tanczos (Whakatane-Ohope Ward), Hans Tiakiwai (Taneatua-Waimana Ward), Gavin Dennis, Wilson James, Gerard van Beek (Rangitaiki Ward), and Hinerangi Goodman (Galatea-Murupara Ward).

Dale says the final declaration of results will be printed in the Tuesday, October 22 2019 edition of the Whakatane Beacon and will also be made available on the Whakatane District Council website.

The Inaugural Council meeting of the new triennium will commence with a pohiri to welcome elected members at 1pm on Friday, October 25 2019 at the Whakatane District Council Civic Centre.

Source: SunLive.co.nz